Wednesday, December 24, 2008

Timothy Chambers: Important lessons for kids in hard facts about Santa

Timothy Chambers: Important lessons for kids in hard facts about Santa

Good not always rewarded in harsh light of real world
Published  

 https://www.chron.com/opinion/outlook/article/Timothy-Chambers-Important-lessons-for-kids-in-1775423.php

Saturday, December 1, 2007

How Doctors Think [Letter] by Timothy Chambers

 

How Doctors Think

Dr. Jerome Groopman ’72, ’76 P&S’ excellent essay, “Flesh-and-Blood Decision-Making” (July/August), highlights a perennial irony: Life is understood backward, but must be lived forward.
Since life is understood backward, classroom lectures overflow with the benefits of hindsight. Thus we peruse case studies that presuppose omniscience, armed with theories presuming omnipotence. But life is lived forward, with all the imperfections that implies. To face a crisis in real time involves limited powers and a shadowy grasp of the facts.
Given such constraints, what else can we do but deploy “heuristics,” which can flexibly adapt as further facts come to light?
While Groopman’s essay focuses on the medical classroom’s inability to impart real-time medical judgment, I wonder whether this might apply more generally — for starters, to ethics, government and business. Even the riverboat pilot, as Mark Twain observed, needs more than mere memory: “There are two higher qualities which [the pilot] must also have. [The pilot] must have good and quick judgment and decision, and a cool, calm courage that no peril can shake (Life on the Mississippi, 1883).”
By illustrating the difference between classroom instruction and real-time decision-making, Groopman offers not just a portrait of medicine but a picture of the human condition.
Timothy Chambers
Department of Philosophy
University of Hartford (Conn.)

Timothy Chambers, "My Friend Was A Poem"

Timothy Chambers, "My Friend Was A Poem"

 https://www.scribd.com/document/683182/Timothy-Chambers-My-Friend-Was-A-Poem

 Timothy Chambers, Timothy Chambers Hartford, Timothy Chambers West Hartford, Timothy Chambers Brown University, Timothy Chambers Harvard University, Timothy Chambers philosophy

Saturday, June 2, 2007

Timothy Chambers, "Nature, Nurture? How About Both?" [letter] (2007)

NATURE, NURTURE? HOW ABOUT BOTH?

THE HARTFORD COURANTJune 2, 2007
As one who as co-authored articles in neuroscience, I was fascinated by the front-page story on the brain's role in our abilities to empathize and moralize [May 29, "We Can't Help But Do Good"]. But as one who has also written about ethics, I worry that the philosophical conclusions the article draws are hasty and flawed. Two of these conclusions merit particular attention.
Because "morality arises from basic brain activities," we're told, our values are "not 'handed down' by philosophers and clergy, but 'handed up' [as] an outgrowth of our brain's basic tendencies." But this ignores another, equally scientific, fact: A child who is raised in chaotic, valueless surroundings will, far more often than not, grow up to bear a pathological lack of conscience.
For this reason, it's best to view nature and nurture as partners, not rivals, in crafting the adult moral faculties we take for granted.
Nature indeed "hands up" a brain that is amazingly receptive to learning values. But then it's necessary for the environment -- in the form of conscientious parents and mentors -- to "hand down" the specific values to that receptive brain. Otherwise, like a seeded field that lacks hands to tend it, the brain's ethical potential will fail to achieve fruition.
Another "troubling question," according to the article, is that neuroscience reduces "morality and immorality to brain chemistry -- rather than free will," and that this "might diminish the importance of personal responsibility."
A little reflection shows why this is an overreaction. We've long known that our capacity to use language is ingrained in various brain centers. Does this mean that we use language robotically? Does it mean that I have no choice over the words I'm writing now, or would lack responsibility if my words were libelous? Clearly not. But if brain-based language centers don't threaten our free use of language, it's unclear why brain-based ethical centers should threaten free will, either.
Beneath both of these errors, I imagine, lies a more general worry: that if we can scientifically explain our astonishing human abilities, then this somehow makes those abilities less astonishing. I disagree. After all, embryologists have come a long way toward describing how a zygote becomes a full-term infant. Does that make childbirth any less of a miracle? I think not.
Timothy Chambers
West Hartford
The writer teaches philosophy at the University of Hartford.